Press release

Is Automotive brand loyalty a myth?

81% of used/76% of new car owners repeat buy the same type (used/new) of car.

  • 68% of used/47% of new car owners change brand between purchase
  • Volkswagen tops the list as most brand loyal, with 26% of VW owners repeat buying
  • BMW least likely brand to drive loyalty, with just 9% of BMW owners repeat buying
  • Trust key driver in brand loyalty, but aftersales least influential in driving a repeat purchase

19th February 2017 – London:In a new study into car purchasing trends, Auto Trader, the UK’s largest marketplace for new and used cars, has revealed that consumers are habitual buyers, except when it comes to the car brand. The survey of c.1,000 UK consumers, revealed that for their next purchase an overwhelming majority of used (81%) and new (76%) car buyers would choose the same type (used or new) of vehicle again.

Whilst slightly more than one in five (22%) of those that owned a used car replaced it with a new one, the findings run contrary to a commonly held belief that consumers are more likely to ‘upgrade’ to a new car if they previously drove a used vehicle of the same brand. In fact, used car buyers are nearly 20% less likely to switch between car types than new car owners.

However, our research showed that 60% of all car buyers are open to considering a brand new vehicle, with a third of all buyers open to new or used. The introduction of thousands of virtual new vehicles on Auto Trader in 2016 has helped give consumers more choice when in the market for their next car, opening up all available options in search results for new and used models.

Nick King, Insight Director, Auto Trader, commented: “It’s clear that when it comes to buying a car consumers are habitual buyers; we like to stick to what we know. However, our research shows that dealers have a very strong opportunity to influence their buying behaviour early on in the purchasing process. By providing a fully transparent customer experience, coupled with a choice of cars that are in tune with the local market not only helps secure a sale, but also one that produces the best margin.

The habitual buying behaviour of consumers is also present when it comes to the body-type of the car, with an average of 41% of new car buyers likely to stick to the same as they previously purchased. New hatchback drivers are the most loyal, with 38% of those surveyed who owned one, chose to repeat buy. Interestingly there is growth in loyalty for SUV and 4×4 purchases, with a respective 17% and 7% increase in repeat purchases. Superminis and convertibles recorded the biggest decline in repeat purchases, falling from 6% – 5% and 5% to 3% respectively.

Brand (dis)loyalty

Consumer loyalty takes a fall however when it comes to the make of vehicle, with a significant 68% of used car buyers and 47% of new changing brands between purchases. Whilst loyalty slowly increases with age – 38% of new car buyers aged 55-64 always purchase the same make, compared with 33% of 25-34 year olds – the majority of consumers still like to change brands at all life stages. This fickle behaviour is supported by Auto Trader’s own data, which show that less than one in four part-exchange enquiries were for the same brand of car.

When it comes to the type of car brand consumers are most loyal to, volume (Ford, Vauxhall, Honda, Nissan, Toyota, Kia, Hyundai) tops premium (Audi, BMW, Mercedes Benz, Volkswagen), with 25% of volume owners repeat buying, compared with just 16% of premium. However, of all the car brands Volkswagen was identified as the most likely to drive loyalty, with 26% of new VW owners stating they always purchase the same make. This was in contrast to BMW, which was revealed to be the least loyal brand, with just 9% of new owners sticking to the German car maker.

The key to loyalty

Revealingly, when it came to the factors that drove brand loyalty, trust was by far the most influential, with 71% of consumers identifying it as the primary reason for choosing the same make of car. This was followed by brand image and price, both recording 63%. Notably, at 47%, a positive aftersales experience ranked the lowest driving factor. For those new car buyers that chose a different make, a desire for change ranked the highest motivation at 74%, closely followed by price at 68%.

Nick continued: “A targeted marketing campaign which employs the right advert, aimed at the right audience, and on the right channel, can be very effective in directing buyers to not only a new car, but also to a specific brand. ”

For dealers, the research revealed that new car buyers are more loyal than used car buyers, with over half (53%) choosing to revisit for a second purchase. Previously positive experiences (75%) coupled with attractive deals offered by the dealerships (70%) were the most highly ranked reasons new car buyers were enticed back to the same dealership.

Methodology

Auto Trader interviewed a nationally representative sample of c.1, 000 UK consumers, of which c.500 purchased a new car in the last six months and c.500 purchased a used car.

About Auto Trader

Auto Trader Group plc is the UK and Ireland’s largest digital automotive marketplace. Auto Trader sits at the heart of the UK’s vehicle buying process and its primary activity is to help vehicle retailers compete effectively on the marketplace in order to sell more vehicles, faster. Auto Trader listed on the London Stock Exchange in March 2015 and is now a member of the FTSE 250 Index.

The marketplace brings together the largest and most engaged consumer audience. Auto Trader has over 90% prompted brand awareness and attracts circa 60 million cross platform visits each month, with circa 70% of visits coming through mobile devices.

The marketplace also has the largest pool of vehicle sellers (listing more than 420,000 cars each day) with over 80% of UK automotive retailers advertising on autotrader.co.uk.

For all trade media enquiries, please contact:

Andrew Nankervis – Senior PR Manager, Auto Trader

Email: andrew.nankervis@autotrader.co.uk

Tel: 020 374 77 234

We've extended the deadline to complete our digital retailing survey being run in partnership with the @RMI_NFDA and ICDP. Complete the survey before Friday to receive a personalised benchmark report👉https://t.co/qjQqIedy43 https://t.co/N3CLR386Uz
Join our next webinar where we’ll be sharing how you can sell vehicles at pace, whilst extracting the most profit and ensuring you allow time to restock and optimise your forecourt. Register now👉https://t.co/5dI2g8GX3Z https://t.co/ZOfgM21yU7
What do Canadian Thanksgiving and @AndrewKorpela's appetite have to do with buying a car online? Find out in this week's tip of the week where we share some tips on how to grab the attention of a growing buyer segment. https://t.co/Eilwe3LhXm
The speed at which used cars sell continues to remain far below what we saw before the pandemic, with last months analysis showing that it took a median of just 24 days for used cars to sell, 3 days quicker than in August. https://t.co/nl83T3y2Wl
Fantastic news 🥳 A huge thank you to everyone that voted for us this year - we're very proud and delighted that our retailer partners have gotten so much value from our platform, particularity during such a challenging period for our industry https://t.co/0xXHDcYemG
COP26 has been dominating headlines over the last few weeks. But what exactly is it? What impact could it have on the automotive industry and why does it matter to you? https://t.co/nGyGxeZvzN
Find out how @HendyGroup, @LookersGroup, @westwaynissan and @PeterVardy are embracing the electric vehicle revolution and enticing consumers into making the switch👉https://t.co/o9S11O5QXS https://t.co/KU8wBqwOXH
In our latest market update, we share our latest audience data and look at whether we are continuing to see strong levels of demand from consumers. https://t.co/p2DSkN8cAv
It's Friday which can only mean 1 thing. It's tip of the week time! In this episode, @AndrewKorpela goes through the findings of the telephone phase of our mystery shopping and explains how you can make the most from a telephone enquiry. https://t.co/Mg0UtWa3aM
September was a month of records for the automotive industry. But we also saw some unexpected challenges and opportunities. Find out more in our latest Market Intelligence report which details our latest insights along with the impact of the fuel crisis👉https://t.co/blOWIg8ZY7 https://t.co/v7SZuYcRM4

Auto Trader Group plc
Registered in England (Company number: 09439967)

Auto Trader Limited
Registered in England and Wales (Company number: 03909628)

Registered address:

1 Tony Wilson Place
Manchester
M15 4FN
VAT number: GB 614 8918 20

Keep in touch

We use social media to speak to the UK’s largest car buying audience